Steps and Best Practices for an Effective Compensation Review Process

Employees’ favorite time of the year? Compensation review day! 

It's that decisive moment when their hard work is recognized, achievements celebrated, and areas for growth are thoughtfully discussed. It’s a day when everything that went right (and maybe a little wrong) is weighed and measured, leading to decisions about their well-earned compensation.

It’s a super common misconception that only big companies need to stress about formal compensation reviews. The reality is that businesses of all sizes can reap the rewards of a well-planned and structured review process. No matter if you’re running a startup or a Fortune 500 giant, compensation review is something you can’t afford to overlook! 

Let’s get into the thick of it, so your next compensation review cycle not only runs smoothly but also leaves your employees feeling appreciated, and keeps your budget in check, too!

What is a Compensation Review Process?

A compensation review process is like giving your employee pay and benefits a regular tune-up. It’s when you pause to assess how your team has been performing and determine if their compensation: aspects like salary, bonuses, and benefits, needs an update.

During this process, you'll evaluate each employee's contributions based on several factors: their individual performance, the value they bring to the team, and how they’ve met or exceeded their goals. You’ll also consider market trends, industry standards, and your company’s financial situation. This way, you’re not just throwing out raises or bonuses, but making thoughtful adjustments that reflect the employee’s worth and your business objectives.

Give Compensation Review cycles the Attention It Deserves!

Managing compensation isn't just a checkbox on the HR to-do list, it’s a critical process that deserves your full attention!

23% of employees expressed uncertainty about whether they were paid fairly, making “fair payment” one of the most unfavorable topics in employee surveys. 

What’s even more telling is that less than 75% of individual contributors and supervisors believe they’re being paid fairly. 

Those numbers really say something: employees, in general, are often dissatisfied with their compensation!

So, it’s high time employers start taking this seriously. By giving it some thoughtful consideration and implementing multiple compensation review cycles, companies can keep everything in check and ensure their teams feel valued and appreciated.

Before you dive into a compensation review, it’s important to take a step back and make sure the foundation is solid. Getting the compensation planning process right from the start is key to ensuring that everything that follows is on point. After all, a well-laid foundation makes the entire compensation strategy much stronger.

To get the full picture and understand the essential steps and benefits of the compensation planning process, check out this interesting blog “Essential Steps and Benefits of the Compensation Planning Process”.

Difference Between Compensation Review Process and Compensation Review Cycle

💡Quick Tip for Budget-Friendly & Accurate Compensation

Leverage incentive compensation management automation tools to streamline processes, reduce errors, boost efficiency, and cut costs. By automating tasks like calculation and payout, you can free up valuable time for strategic initiatives and improve overall compensation accuracy and transparency.

Kennect makes incentive compensation a breeze. Forget the hassle of spreadsheets and manual calculations. We handle it all for you, end to end!
Book a demo today!

Steps to Conduct a Fair and Effective Compensation Review

Taking things step by step is crucial, especially when it comes to something as serious as a compensation review. It's not something you want to wing; sticking to a clear process ensures fairness and accuracy.

Step: 1 Determine Leadership for the Review

First things first, you’ll want to identify who’s leading the charge. This could be someone from HR, a senior manager, or a compensation committee. Having the right leadership ensures that the process is organized, and everyone knows who’s responsible for what. Plus, it adds a level of authority to the review.

Step: 2 Identify Objectives and Goals

Next, let’s get clear on what you want to achieve. Are you looking to adjust salaries based on market trends, improve employee morale, or align with company goals? Defining your objectives upfront helps guide the entire process and keeps everyone focused on what really matters.

Step: 3 Evaluate Market Competitiveness

Now it’s time to see how your compensation stacks up against the competition. Research industry standards and benchmarks to determine if you’re offering competitive salaries and benefits. This step is crucial because you want to make sure your pay isn’t just fair but also attractive enough to retain and attract top talent

Step: 4 Review the Employee Benefits Package

Don’t forget about the perks! Take a close look at your employee benefits package—think health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, and any other goodies you offer. Sometimes, a strong benefits package can make up for a lower salary, so it’s important to assess if you’re offering a comprehensive package that meets your employees’ needs.

Step: 5 Decide on Compensation Adjustments

Once you have all the information, it’s time to make some decisions. Based on your findings, you’ll determine if salary adjustments are needed. This could mean raises, bonuses, or even re-evaluating roles and responsibilities. Make sure these adjustments align with your objectives and are fair across the board.

Tips for a Successful Compensation Review Process

A successful compensation review process is built on several key pillars that ensure it stands strong and delivers results. Here are the foundational elements that make it a reality:

1. Aligning with Compensation Philosophy:

Get clear on your compensation philosophy. What do you stand for? Whether it’s paying above market rates or emphasizing internal equity, make sure your philosophy is well-communicated and understood by everyone. This helps set expectations and aligns your team with the company’s goals. A little clarity goes a long way!

2. Ensuring Financial Stability

Are you in a position to offer raises or bonuses? Make sure your budget can support the changes you’re considering. After all, no one wants to promise a raise only to find out the budget doesn’t allow for it. A good review process takes financial realities into account.

3. Prioritizing Pay Equity

Fairness is key! During your review, ensure that pay equity is front and center. This means analyzing salaries across roles, departments, and demographics. Look for any disparities that need addressing. Remember, a workforce that feels valued and treated equitably is more likely to be engaged and productive.

4. Incorporating Employee Feedback

Finally, don’t forget to listen to your employees! Collect feedback on how they perceive their compensation and what they value most. This can provide valuable insights that inform your review process. 

Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them

No process is without its hurdles, and compensation reviews are no exception. While the specifics might vary from one organization to another, there are a few common challenges that most companies face. The good news? There are ways to tackle them head-on. Here's how you can overcome these obstacles and keep things running smoothly:

1️⃣Managing Bias in Compensation Decisions‍

❌Problem: Let’s face it—bias can creep in, even when we’re trying to be as fair as possible. 

✅Solution: The trick here is to establish clear, objective criteria for compensation decisions. Use data-driven tools and performance metrics to guide your choices. And don’t forget to regularly audit your pay practices to catch and correct any unconscious bias. It’s all about making sure everyone gets a fair shake.

2️⃣ Keeping Up with Market Trends

❌Problem: The compensation landscape is always changing, and staying on top of market trends can feel like a full-time job.

✅Solution:  To keep pace, regularly review salary benchmarks and industry reports. Consider joining professional networks or subscribing to compensation surveys that give you the latest insights. This way, you’ll ensure your compensation packages are competitive and help you retain top talent.

3️⃣ Handling Remote Work Compensation

❌Problem: With remote work becoming the norm, figuring out how to compensate remote employees fairly can be tricky. Should you pay based on their location or the company’s headquarters? 

✅Solution: The key is to develop a clear policy that reflects your company’s values and strategy. Communicate openly with your team about how these decisions are made, so there are no surprises. Flexibility and transparency go a long way in navigating this new terrain.

Benefits of an Organized Compensation Review Process

#1 Enhancing Employee Retention and Morale

When employees feel they’re being fairly compensated, they’re more likely to stick around and stay motivated. An organized review process shows your team that you’re serious about recognizing their hard work. It’s not just about the money, it’s about feeling valued. And when employees feel appreciated, their loyalty and morale naturally get a boost.

#2 Ensuring Fair and Competitive Compensation

A well-structured review process helps you stay competitive in the market. It ensures that salaries are in line with industry standards and that there’s fairness across the board. By regularly reviewing compensation, you can adjust pay rates to reflect market changes, making sure you’re not losing top talent to competitors who might be offering just a little bit more.

#3 Aligning Compensation with Organizational Goals

Your compensation strategy should reflect what your company is trying to achieve. An organized review process allows you to align pay with performance and company objectives. Whether it’s rewarding innovation, encouraging collaboration, or driving sales, tying compensation to your goals ensures everyone is working toward the same targets.

The Bottom Line

It’s never too early to rethink and refine your compensation approach. 

Remember, a well-executed compensation review doesn’t just impact paychecks, it aligns your team, fosters transparency, and drives productivity. Your company’s compensation review plan is the backbone of every pay-related decision you make, shaping the way you reward and retain your people. So, take the time to get it right, and watch your organization thrive.

When your compensation review process is strong, your organization thrives, and so do your people.